About Us

One of the most respected and enduring companies in Williamsburg

Benschoten & Carter is one of the most respected and enduring independent insurance agencies in Williamsburg. The owners, Lee Carter and Cathy Carter Huff, were both raised in Williamsburg and each has more than 20 years of insurance experience. Their fathers, James (Jim) D. Carter III & John (Jack) R. Carter, had been with the agency since the 1960s.


We strive to be fair and honest in all our dealings and treat our clients as we would like to be treated. Our personal service stems from our interest in and concern for people.

Call us at 855-899-9836 for a quote

Site Map

California Consumer Privacy